Activity Stream

Filter
Sort By Time Show
Recent Recent Popular Popular Anytime Anytime Last 24 Hours Last 24 Hours Last 7 Days Last 7 Days Last 30 Days Last 30 Days All All Photos Photos Forum Forums Articles Articles Blog Blogs
  • lawsons's Avatar
    36 Minutes Ago
    Some of the videos in the rugby laws app are baffling to me. Look at this one. White 18 gets pinged for playing the ball, just before yellow 9 does...
    0 replies | 3 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    15 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    No, I think Arabcheif is suggesting that ?
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • OB..'s Avatar
    15 Hours Ago
    OB.. replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    So you are saying that he delayed his pass more than normal (in order to try and gain a penalty)?
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    16 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    He should have passed it quicker as he could see Brits was coming He should have passed blind, because on the open side Brits was in the channel ...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Arabcheif's Avatar
    17 Hours Ago
    Arabcheif replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    But he's not slowed anything down though. If anyone has it's the 9. He's picked up the ball and held onto for a second or 2 before passing. If he'd...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    17 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    I hear what you are saying.. I just think you are being too kind to Brits I think he is where he is quite deliberately, he wants to get in...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Arabcheif's Avatar
    17 Hours Ago
    Arabcheif replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    IMO if the 9 throws a normal pass, remembering that at no point is a pass ever thrown in the direction of the ground (unless it slips), the duck in...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    18 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    See this is where we started .. Hit the player and you have a word with the 9 Be careful to pass over the head.of the squatting player (who is...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Arabcheif's Avatar
    18 Hours Ago
    Arabcheif replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    I recall NO doing this too Rich. I disagree with the call in this case. The 9 hasn't passed to anyone. He's just thrown the ball at the retreating...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Rich_NL's Avatar
    18 Hours Ago
    Rich_NL replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    Thank you :) I've seen it once in one of my games where there was no-one realistically available for the ball, and I called play on (IIRC we went...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    19 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    To me getting directly in the passing lane , stopping, remaining there and crouching IS interfering with play. Scrum halves typically pass from...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Phil E's Avatar
    19 Hours Ago
    Phil E replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    That was Brits beef. He made every effort to stay out of the way, dropping to the floor to be out of the way of the pass, and the 9 threw it low...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    19 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    Play on With the caveat that in real life this happens when the player.isnin line with a possible pass, so he very likely was actually...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Rich_NL's Avatar
    19 Hours Ago
    Rich_NL replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    Why are you determined to avoid the question I'm asking? If they are offside and not interfering with play, but the scrumhalf chooses to make them...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • ianh5979's Avatar
    19 Hours Ago
    ianh5979 replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    To me Brits ducked to avoid the passing lane and the SH deliberately passed it low to hit him
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    19 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    What do you mean by milking it If someone is offside and interfering with play then he is liable for a PK. If the scrum half points it out by...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Rich_NL's Avatar
    19 Hours Ago
    Rich_NL replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    So what's your call when the red scrum half milks it - play on, red scrum for accidental offside, red penalty against the offside player, or penalty...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    20 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    rich, Obviously if he is miles from play he is fine. But that hardly needs saying does it ? It's when they run through the channel that things are...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Rich_NL's Avatar
    20 Hours Ago
    Rich_NL replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    Clearly, you made it so. The conversation started about tap&go and looking for the offside call by running into players. Dickie and Pablo offered...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    20 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    So this conversation was about players running right through where the 9 was likely to pass... Well, that was what I was talking about
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Rich_NL's Avatar
    20 Hours Ago
    Rich_NL replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    Of course not, he'd be disrupting the flow of play. He's standing on the blind side, 2 metres behind the passing line to the winger. Clear?
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Phil E's Avatar
    20 Hours Ago
    Phil E replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    https://rugbydump.com/news/schalk-brits-angered-at-cynical-play-by-kahn-fotualii/
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    20 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    Your 17 had lots of yes/no rules, that made it seem pretty automatic ! That's partly what I didn't like Agree that judgement is called for, but...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Arabcheif's Avatar
    20 Hours Ago
    Arabcheif replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    No my post #17 is in keeping with my post #25. #17 was merely stating that I wouldn't automatically blow for an offside and that it would depend on...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    20 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    Where was the player ? Right between the 9 and 10?
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Rich_NL's Avatar
    20 Hours Ago
    Rich_NL replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    My point was about a 9 who clearly and obviously picks out an offside player who's not disrupting the flow of play and throws the ball at him solely...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    20 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    I agree with that. It's different from what you said in post 17 , which I disagreed with
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Arabcheif's Avatar
    21 Hours Ago
    Arabcheif replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    So what's the solution for the retreating offside player? Like I've said, yes if the 9 wants quick ball out to the backs and picks up the ball...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    21 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    But simply being between the 9 and 10 at the critical moment is interfering Which is prety much what zebra says in pint 2
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
  • Pinky's Avatar
    22 Hours Ago
    Pinky replied to a thread [Junior] Tap and Go in Question Forum
    Agree with Zebra and AC - the attacking 9 is not guaranteed a penalty if there is not an opposition free space, just that they will not interfere...
    50 replies | 703 view(s)
More Activity