Activity Stream

Filter
Sort By Time Show
Recent Recent Popular Popular Anytime Anytime Last 24 Hours Last 24 Hours Last 7 Days Last 7 Days Last 30 Days Last 30 Days All All Photos Photos Forum Forums Articles Articles Blog Blogs
  • smeagol's Avatar
    5 Hours Ago
    smeagol replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    Per the letter of the law, I think it's play on. Prior to this thread if this happened in my game, I'd probably go for accidental offside.
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    5 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    In my scenario green didn't charge it down, the ball hit him, and the qu was whether a green player was offside
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • smeagol's Avatar
    6 Hours Ago
    smeagol replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    Given how the law book defines a charge down, IME the player doing the charge down is intentionally playing the ball. If red kicks and green charges...
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • Flish's Avatar
    6 Hours Ago
    Flish replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    Must have missed that one, can someone find / link to it as if a charge down counts as playing the ball then I might have to rethink that thought...
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • Flish's Avatar
    6 Hours Ago
    I think that fits, certainly in the lower ladies / social leagues and with the the new game on principles they are trying all they can to get games...
    3 replies | 85 view(s)
  • pombok's Avatar
    8 Hours Ago
    Good point, and you got me digging deeper into the regs. Reg 13 only states for "adult competitions", but 13.2.1(b) goes on to say: ...
    3 replies | 85 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    9 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread YC return in What's the decision?
    not sure that necessarily has to have the the same answer. Yes, I think I would let him on. . . Ten playing minutes have elapsed .. the ball is...
    29 replies | 467 view(s)
  • chbg's Avatar
    9 Hours Ago
    chbg replied to a thread YC return in What's the decision?
    I generally wait until the next dead ball, but, TBH, 20 secs less than 10 mins playing time is definitely no; 5 seconds less may well depend on how...
    29 replies | 467 view(s)
  • chbg's Avatar
    9 Hours Ago
    chbg replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    I agree with both scenarios.
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • thepercy's Avatar
    9 Hours Ago
    thepercy replied to a thread YC return in What's the decision?
    I'll answer the question with a question. If there was a knock on, no advantage, scrum. Look at your watch, less than 10 minutes playing time has...
    29 replies | 467 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    10 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread YC return in What's the decision?
    We referees gain that respect by being impartial and keeping to the Law
    29 replies | 467 view(s)
  • TheBFG's Avatar
    10 Hours Ago
    TheBFG replied to a thread YC return in What's the decision?
    the referee is the sole judge of fact and of Law. It is essential that all players respect the referee's decisions at all times :wink:
    29 replies | 467 view(s)
  • didds's Avatar
    10 Hours Ago
    didds replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    didnt we do this a couple of weeks back? that's not a dig - admins may be able to merge the two calls or summat didds
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • SimonSmith's Avatar
    10 Hours Ago
    SimonSmith replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    Someone tell me what I have wrong here as a couple of posters have said that there is no offside from a charge down. Blue 6 charges White 10's...
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    12 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread YC return in What's the decision?
    Even better, rather than dissembling about the time, is to do the right thing, surely. But if you like transport the scenario to the professional...
    29 replies | 467 view(s)
  • OB..'s Avatar
    12 Hours Ago
    OB.. replied to a thread YC return in What's the decision?
    Very true. I often get coaches asking me why their player is not back on yet because the 10 minutes has elapsed. I simply point out that it is...
    29 replies | 467 view(s)
  • Flish's Avatar
    13 Hours Ago
    Flish replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    No, I don't believe he was, as described there was no deliberate or intended act to play the ball , I mean there's no offside for charging down and...
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    14 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    Yes, but is the right answer, in fact. Is he offside or not ?
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • Flish's Avatar
    15 Hours Ago
    First question is does the man off (woman off?) law apply? You say "Normal uncontested scrum law would mean ..." but does it apply to the Ladies? I'm...
    3 replies | 85 view(s)
  • L'irlandais's Avatar
    15 Hours Ago
    L'irlandais replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    I agree with Rich_NL on that point, it is better to hold your hand up and say Sorry I was wrong to have blown. Let’s restart with a scrum. ...
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • TheBFG's Avatar
    16 Hours Ago
    TheBFG replied to a thread YC return in What's the decision?
    You're the only one that knows the time on the bin, wait until the conversion is taken and then call him back on, problem solved!
    29 replies | 467 view(s)
  • Rich_NL's Avatar
    16 Hours Ago
    Rich_NL replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    That's why I try to call things clearly before I blow the whistle ;) I generally say "leave it green" or "get onside" as loudly and promptly as I...
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • crossref's Avatar
    16 Hours Ago
    crossref replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    In my case I don't think I would have tried to sell 'accidental offside" as G7 actions were not accidental .. it was either play on or clearly a PK....
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • Marc Wakeham's Avatar
    16 Hours Ago
    Marc Wakeham replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    If yo utry to "sell" it like this you are going to have to have a good story. It is either Offside or play on. Once you blow it is either PK or scrum...
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
  • pombok's Avatar
    17 Hours Ago
    I had a game a couple of weeks ago that had me scratching my head. Womens NC2 game so England Rugby Regulation 16 and 16 Amendment 1 come into...
    3 replies | 85 view(s)
  • Rich_NL's Avatar
    17 Hours Ago
    Rich_NL replied to a thread [Law] Offside or not in Question Forum
    Letter of the law seems clearly "play on", but I agree with chbg - if you haven't called it one way or the other, and have blown the whistle already,...
    31 replies | 521 view(s)
More Activity