• Twitter

  • Bryce Lawrence may not referee in South Africa

    In a recent article on PlanetRugby Bryce Lawrence has stated that he may not referee games in South Africa.

    the article is reproduced below:


    Under fire New Zealand-born referee Bryce Lawrence says he won't officiate in South Africa if he fears for his safety.

    This comes after his performance at last month's World Cup quarter-final between the Springboks and Australia.

    Lawrence's control of the October 9 quarter-final, won 11-9 by Australia to end South Africa' reign as world champions, was strongly criticised by Springbok players, coaching staff and fans.

    Retiring Springbok captain John Smit said "the one positive (of retirement) is that I won't ever have to be reffed by him again" and a South African fan began a Facebook campaign entitled "Petition To Stop Bryce Lawrence Ever Reffing A Rugby Game Again."

    Lawrence said in a radio interview on Wednesday he would not referee in South Africa "if there's any personal threat or I have concerns about my safety".

    The fact that Bryce Lawrence needs to think this shows how fast our game is currently sliding down a slippery slope, the loss of respect for those that go out there to try and referee a game of rugby as best they can, whilst 30 players try and see how far they can bend the laws is unprecedented.

    While Bryce may not have refereed his best game at the Rugby World Cup, he certainly should not have to fear for his safety, in any other job the harassment and bullying aimed at him would be unlawful, breaching countless company policies and legal legislation, but because he's a referee he's fair game, right? WRONG!

    It's a very famous saying for most professionals in any trade that you are only as good as your last balls up, and whilst the perception of this phase is true, the reality is very different. Even at this level referees learn from their experiences at every game, and to expect a referee to make no mistakes, is as futile as expecting no knock ons in a game.

    It matters not of you do or don't like a certain referees style, after all you can't actually say you don't like them, unless you actually know them, as a player and coach you need to adapt. At this level the coaches will have all the information on the referee for the game ahead, they will know where they award most penalties, and where they seem to not award many, they will see trends in their games and try to exploit them, this is the professional age of rugby, and the rewards for getting it right are rich.

    So the fact that at the last 2 world cups no less than 5 referees have been lambasted with criticism (Barnes v NZ 2007, Barnes v Wales 2011, Rolland v Wales 2011, Owens v Samoa 2011, Lawrence v South Africa 2011, Joubert v France 2011), and most with some sort of threat of physical abuse or death threats is a sad state of affairs.

    What good is our game if certain referees cannot referee at certain places because of certain fans threatening them? In the end all referees will be a target because someone won't have liked a decision they have made.

    Time to grow up people, be passionate, be supportive, but most of all be respectful to all involved, players, coaches, support staff, officials and other supporters.
  • Recent Activity Widget


    Trouble at Los Millos

    Thread Starter: didds

    Not good. And some rather odd decisions made wrt appointments it seems, for the protection of everybody... .http://www.rugbyworld.com/news/ugly-scenes-spain-fail-automatically-qualify-rwc2019-90774 Didds

    Last Post By: crossref 36 Minutes Ago Go to last post

    Post-ruck tackle area?

    Thread Starter: Rich_NL

    Blue 11 tackles red 14 on a break, and immediately gets to his feet to jackal (through the gate, legally), forming a ruck. Red 13 clears him out, and they end up off feet and clear of the ruck/tackle area, which is now just red 14 on the ground presenting the ball backwards. Blue 15 runs in from...

    Last Post By: Decorily 1 Hour Ago Go to last post

    Eng Ireland 29 decisions in 28 minutes..

    Thread Starter: Butters

    I posted this on Facebook and got quite a bit of feedback. Would appreciate the opinion of experts. Not saying all of my points are right, but I am fairly sure some of them are... Have done it with MM:SS against the game clock.. Many congratulations to Ireland winning the Grand Slam on...

    Last Post By: Decorily 1 Hour Ago Go to last post

    Accidental offside

    Thread Starter: ChrisR

    I'm surprised that this hasn't come up. Here's the video from England v. Ireland https://youtu.be/r1zhln8ExWI?t=1137 Clearly an accidental offside but should play have been stopped for the Ireland scrum? I think not. Play should only have been stopped if England gain an advantage. Clearly...

    Last Post By: Taff 2 Hours Ago Go to last post

    Scotland vs Italy - Charge down?

    Thread Starter: merge

    At 36 minutes on the game clock: https://youtu.be/95WJjTFFeTc?t=42m47s Blue 10 kicks ahead and chases his own kick. It bounces and White 9 fly hacks the ball back towards Blue 10 sticks his left hand out close to his side and knocks the ball forward. In real time it looked a bit wrong (not the...

    Last Post By: crossref 3 Hours Ago Go to last post