Search:

Type: Posts; User: frenchie851; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 2 1 2

Search: Search took 0.02 seconds.

  1. Replies
    5
    Views
    212

    [Scrum] Re: Back row angle at scrum

    If the flankers actions are causing the Prop to not drive straight and in at an angle just penalise the Prop. It is up to the prop to tell the flanker to stop what he is doing so that the prop...
  2. Replies
    35
    Views
    1,228

    [Tackle] Re: Tackle Release

    unless he called it to be a ruck all ready then when the red player goes to ground and blue is still holding the ball red should let go.
  3. [Ruck] Re: Should the ladder/caterpiller ruck be outlawed?

    I agree with this. I think this would stop it because the 9 wouldn't trust the clumsy forward to heel the ball back through 5 people.
  4. Replies
    9
    Views
    468

    [Ruck] Re: Picking the ball up from the ruck

    Hi,

    Can the ref hear the comms during the game or is it just for the live stream?
  5. Replies
    28
    Views
    1,912

    [Law] Re: Offside support players

    Good try and good Forwards play by 5.

    He is just taking 'the cheating line'. Not law breaking but 'cheating' in the sense that he is taking the shortest possible route to where he predicts a...
  6. Replies
    43
    Views
    1,866

    [Law] Re: Penalty at end of game

    That is different, a grey area has been created with the kick directly going into touch because you've looked for a grey area. A grey area did not even exist to me because in plain English it is...
  7. Replies
    43
    Views
    1,866

    [Law] Re: Penalty at end of game

    I am personally reffing this with how I believe the equity of the laws intended. If it bounces and goes into touch I am playing the line out. If you played the line out there is no way the defending...
  8. Replies
    21
    Views
    1,189

    [Law] Re: When to make the mark

    What I do in Yellow Card situations is (this has just developed over the 1st year of reffing):

    . Blow whistle, Switch clock off, tell every one the clock is off. At this point I make a mark (so...
  9. [Tackle] Re: South African schoolboy rugby viral tackle video

    I'm willing to put my neck on the line here..... There is no way I am sending someone off for that on a Saturday.

    I defy anyone could day that is a def red at first time of seeing it, at full...
  10. Replies
    30
    Views
    2,336

    [Law] Re: Try annulled for foul play

    The way I see it is that the first act of foul play is from Williams.

    He is not at the back foot, has come in at the side to clear green 9 out. Was no need for that and ultimately what lead to it...
  11. [Law] Re: Can you lift a team mate to block a conversion or drop kick?

    Recently we were doing a 15 on 15 team run through on a Thursday night. (Lvl 7).

    As I am a relativly undersized BR player I can be lifted by one player quite easily (there are about 2 players in...
  12. Thread: Advantage

    by frenchie851
    Replies
    12
    Views
    956

    [Law] Re: Advantage

    Another variation you might see is a significantly longer pen advantage when the non offending team are on the oppositions goal line, compared to when the non offending team are in their own 22 for...
  13. Replies
    32
    Views
    1,856

    [Tackle] Re: You can't do that it's Dangerous play!

    Would you penalise the 'high knee action'?

    It looks to me that the OP is a level 7 referee, I hope I am not speaking for him and out of turn but I would say no he (and I wouldn't). Simple reason...
  14. Replies
    23
    Views
    1,652

    [Ruck] Re: Diving on the ball as leaving the ruck?

    I think we are making this too complicated.

    When the scrum half goes to play the ball there are time when the ball is not stationary but instead the ball is 'coming out of the ruck'. Surely this...
  15. Replies
    23
    Views
    1,652

    [Ruck] Re: Diving on the ball as leaving the ruck?

    The law says:

    "Fall over the ball as it is coming out of a ruck."

    So I suppose you need to interpret what is "coming out of the ruck" and what is "clearly out of a ruck".
  16. Replies
    23
    Views
    1,652

    [Ruck] Re: Diving on the ball as leaving the ruck?

    When the ball is clearly out then I would see it as open play. But for a player to dive on it they would have to come from an onside position?
  17. Replies
    28
    Views
    2,105

    [Law] Re: Quiz #3 Pin Ball

    Learnt something from this one. I needed to revive of 6.10!
  18. Replies
    26
    Views
    1,716

    [Tackle] Re: Mark + No 10 metres

    Spot on in my opinion, deliberate attempt of a tackle I would give PK. They are called Laws for these exact reasons, as they are laws they are open to our interpretation and you can interpret the law...
  19. Replies
    28
    Views
    2,105

    [Law] Re: Quiz #3 Pin Ball

    In using the word advantage I have muddied the waters (because of the obvious use of 'advantage' in the game).

    What I am trying to say is that they have profited from the ball bouncing off the...
  20. Replies
    28
    Views
    2,105

    [Law] Re: Quiz #3 Pin Ball

    If the ball hits the ref and (critically) one team gains an advantage then you stop the game and there is a scrum.

    Do you not therefore give the scrum to the team that 'did not gain the...
  21. [Law] Re: How long before kick off should one arrive at the club ?

    Same for me. 1hr 15 I aim for. Gives me time to be held up in traffic..... or get lost.
  22. Replies
    49
    Views
    4,687

    Re: Collapsing Rucks

    I had to go back and listen to this pod cast.

    As Brian Moore said at the end, I can see both POVs.

    I have always thought that if you take another player to ground in a ruck but you do it way...
  23. Replies
    21
    Views
    2,977

    Re: ARs and scrums

    at the community level I ask the two guys I give a flag to to mark the opposition back 5m at every scrum, this covers attack and defence.

    As a AR myself (@Lvl 5 or 6 )I have been asked to stay...
  24. Replies
    63
    Views
    4,089

    [Law] Re: After final whistle

    Cheers for the heads up. I wouldn't have known that.
  25. Replies
    63
    Views
    4,089

    [Law] Re: After final whistle

    Ref it exactly the same as you would during the game.
Results 1 to 25 of 46
Page 1 of 2 1 2