Search:

Type: Posts; User: CrouchTPEngage; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 17 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.10 seconds.

  1. Replies
    32
    Views
    1,009

    [In-goal] Re: Touch in goal

    21.17 applies here ?
    When a player carrying the ball is held up in the in-goal so that the player cannot ground or play the ball, the ball is dead. Play restarts with a five-metre scrum, in line...
  2. [Law] Re: Time up or restart. Conversion over end of game time

    You are confirming my understanding. phew !
    Follow on question about a similar time related issue I have had in 2 close games this season. Winning team in possession and going thru a pick and go...
  3. [Law] Time up or restart. Conversion over end of game time

    Try is awarded on 79 mins. Conversion kicker makes sure conversion takes 90 secs. Do I end the the game after the conversion or must we restart ?
    I had 2 different opinions in my game yesterday....
  4. [Ruck] Re: Should the ladder/caterpiller ruck be outlawed?

    I wonder how many refs on here often give turnovers once the 5 seconds after the "Use!" is called ?
  5. [Ruck] Should the ladder/caterpiller ruck be outlawed?

    https://www.rugbypass.com/news/exeters-use-of-controversial-ladder-rucking-loophole-criticised

    Interesting article about the use of the caterpiller or "ladder" ruck.
    Slowing down the game. Giving...
  6. Replies
    55
    Views
    2,912

    Re: [RWC] Eng v SA

    + 1 vote for Angus Gardner ! A superb ref.
    Especially liked that famous time he changed his mind after TJ Perenara debated a decision. Showed real empathy for me, that did !
  7. [Scrum] Re: "Modern" interpretations of scrum dominance.

    I have some sympathy with this view. Indeed I found myself saying "Scrums are not Penalty Generators !" to the captian of the dominant scrummaging team at my last game. He was under the opinion that...
  8. Replies
    55
    Views
    2,912

    Re: [RWC] Eng v SA

    The better team won on the day. No complaints. Now, I need to try to learn something from Mr Garces. I was being asked by people watching with me "What was that penalty for?" - For some of the scrum...
  9. Replies
    79
    Views
    2,972

    [INTERNATIONAL] Re: That haka

    Thanks for that. Learning something today :-)
    If its not mandatory to face it , then I would just tell them to do some practice passing drills in their own 22.
    No problems if you want to do...
  10. Re: Do you allow 9's to dummy it at the back of a ruck ?

    Cheers.
    You just reminded me. First time in for 2 seasons. I gave turnover scrum for delaying too long at back of scrum. Close game, with only 1 minute left. there were a couple of very long...
  11. Do you allow 9's to dummy it at the back of a ruck ?

    https://drive.google.com/file/d/1GGOiR1VoQpwk_QOiwq59-kWwihx_m8ol/view?usp=sharing

    Example video from today's Leicester Saracens game. If you believe that the 9 is intending to deceive defeneders...
  12. Replies
    55
    Views
    2,243

    [RWC] Re: Knock on inside a maul

    Have now had the chance to re-watch it a few times, in slow-mo. Can't the TMO do that too? This is a semi-final of a World Cup for Pete's sake !

    As others have hinted, I am now convinced it is...
  13. Replies
    42
    Views
    1,829

    [Law] Re: Penalty Kick at Goal Rules

    I know that conversion attempts explicitly forbid defenders lifting teammates to block a kick. But do we think it's legal to deflect or block a penalty by liftin a team-mate into the air, close the...
  14. [Law] Re: PK Shot at goal and arrival of kicking tee. What would you do ?

    I was thinking Law 8.20
    "The intention to kick can be communicated by the arrival of the kicking tee"

    EDIT
    Just re-read your law reference which is more about a "person" entering the field...
  15. [Law] Re: PK Shot at goal and arrival of kicking tee. What would you do ?

    OK. What I did :
    I did smile. But I wasn't 100% convinced they would have said nothing if they hadnt been caught.
    I move the kick 10 metres forward and let blue captain choose. He chose to kick...
  16. [Law] PK Shot at goal and arrival of kicking tee. What would you do ?

    Recent colts game I reffed. Will tell you what I did later.

    Final 6 minutes of game. Red v Blue. Red are leading 19-15. I award Blue a PK , 22 metres from goal about 20 metres in from touch. So,...
  17. [Law] Re: Wales v Georgia Gareth Davies deliverate knock-on or not

    Yep. Fairly risky and reckless thing to do. He could have easily been yellow-carded doing that next time.
    Like I said, in my level, I dont get TMO replays, so I would probably have given it a...
  18. [Law] Re: Ball in or out ruck ( england v tonga )

    Cheers crossref ! I know what you mean.
    I think the key point , to the original OP, is that Yes, we must also now consider more than just the players who are on their feet. Moreover, because...
  19. [Law] Wales v Georgia Gareth Davies deliverate knock-on or not

    Hope you can see this video link ( Upon feedback I can alter )
    https://drive.google.com/file/d/1D48vEkjc93M-btXrVa-aDow6oxvDxVAK/view?usp=sharing_eil&ts=5d88abec

    Georgia break the line and ,...
  20. [Law] Re: Ball in or out ruck ( england v tonga )

    There was a law clarification on this after the England New Zealand incident where Courteney Lawes was adjudged offisde which disallowed an England try. I took from that that the "hindmost" line now...
  21. Re: Gaining advantage by making ball dead

    Just in case people didnt know, if he kicks it out directly (from a PK) then you must play the lineout - right ? ( He has to tap it first and THEN kick it out if he wants to end the half )
  22. Thread: Dummy

    by CrouchTPEngage
    Replies
    6
    Views
    232

    [Ruck] Re: Dummy

    Once of my bugbears I'm afraid. Frequently seen at elite level is the 9 , at the back of a ruck, dipping shoulders or placing his hands on the ball (not picking it up) and making a little dip of the...
  23. Replies
    57
    Views
    2,398

    [Law] Re: Charge down & off side

    Top Tip -
    I've often watched refs , at much higher level than mine, who shout "Touched !" after an attempted charge-down ( where the ball glances a finger-tip of an attempted charge-down but still...
  24. [Maul] Re: After Maul Collapse. Can opposition play it with hands when off feet? Bath v Glos

    Yeah ignore that. Sorry ! It was my mobile phone getting a text when I was recording it. Not on the game audio.
    Lol
  25. [Maul] Re: After Maul Collapse. Can opposition play it with hands when off feet? Bath v Glos

    Admittedly I had to watch it a few times but ,for me, I see the mai
    ul collapse, the ball is on the ground and the Gloucester player is on his feet trying to play it . It looks available . Then Toby...
Results 1 to 25 of 405
Page 1 of 17 1 2 3 4