Search:

Type: Posts; User: SimonSmith; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.11 seconds.

  1. Replies
    11
    Views
    212

    [Law] Re: Is there a definition of a kicking tee?

    Is the right answer
  2. Replies
    12
    Views
    370

    Re: Pulling a player from the ruck/tackle

    "We" allow gator rolls because TPTB have told us.
    There is a number of us who believe that they are both illegal and dangerous.
  3. Replies
    22
    Views
    681

    Re: advantage story

    Because at some point, if they're only getting 0.5m under pressure, you're going to decide that the advantage isn't real. SO you bring it back.
    In my experience, Coaches, Ref Coaches and players are...
  4. Replies
    37
    Views
    2,128

    [Law] Re: Hand Off or Fend to the face/head/neck

    In some regions there are some variations with regulations which stipulate no hand off above shoulder height.[/QUOTE]

    Under 18 over here.
  5. [Law] Re: Penalty offence by team that didn't knock on while playing advantage for the KO

    And you, just as mischievously, are asking questions you already know the answer to
  6. [Law] Re: Penalty offence by team that didn't knock on while playing advantage for the KO

    I tell 9 and the captain before kick off that if they don't want the advantage, just tell me and I'll blow.
  7. Replies
    50
    Views
    1,320

    [Golden Oldies] Re: Reports on Referee post-game on WhosTheRef

    If you let them do it to you, you're letting them do it to the next poor soul...
  8. Replies
    37
    Views
    2,128

    [Law] Re: Hand Off or Fend to the face/head/neck

    Until you have your reasoning square in your head, don't do this. For change to happen, there needs to be a good reason.

    The only reason to stop the hand offs is excessive force - in other words,...
  9. Re: Scrum Law 19.28 - scrum half position - your advice please

    Sorry, I disagree. I coach a 9 who starts legal and then goes to his back foot as a default defensive position in certain field areas. He's quick enough to beat the heel and pick up.
  10. [Line out] Re: Saracens vs Munster European Rugby Champions Cup

    Is your argument that the Medic shouldn't have received any sanction at all?
  11. Replies
    38
    Views
    1,394

    [Law] Re: Referees using player's names

    I only address Captains by first name.

    If it's "Dave, your players need to try harder to stay on their feet" I'm making use of downtime to have a chat and stop a trend emerging.


    "Blue...
  12. [Assistant Referees] Re: Pushed by player - my fault for being in field of play?

    For someone who is usually such a stickler for Law, your determination to avoid in this situation is...unusual.
  13. Re: Touch call before fracas (Exeter/Saracens)

    BBC match report:



    which tallies with the commentary from the telly.[/FONT][/COLOR]
  14. Re: Touch call before fracas (Exeter/Saracens)

    "I'd failed the HIA. Clearly I was not in possession of all my faculties"
  15. [Assistant Referees] Re: Pushed by player - my fault for being in field of play?

    Your question was badly worded and didn't make it clear that these things were simultaneous. Your accusation of sidestepping is incorrect and offensive.

    In that situation:
    Red card the shover....
  16. [Assistant Referees] Re: Pushed by player - my fault for being in field of play?

    Yes I would red card anyone who shoved a TJ.
    Your second question is circumstance contingent.

    You're the one ignoring law. So let me ask you:
    Would you, or would you not, red card a player who...
  17. Replies
    26
    Views
    1,671

    Re: The crusade continues

    Absolutely right Ian. Numbers only give you...numbers. They don't speak to things like acceptance, integration or any other non-quantifiable measures.
  18. [Assistant Referees] Re: Pushed by player - my fault for being in field of play?

    I'm not twisting words, you're abrogating your responsibility under Law and not protecting Match Officials.
  19. [Assistant Referees] Re: Pushed by player - my fault for being in field of play?

    Conversion attempt by home.
    One flag up (home side player TJ), one down.
    Referee agreed with Home TJ.

    Away side started levelling verbal abuse at TJ (which was RC worthy). He pithily suggested...
  20. [Assistant Referees] Re: Pushed by player - my fault for being in field of play?

    When people wonder how we have trouble attracting and retaining Match Officials of any kind, TJ, AR or Referee, let's all point them to this thread where referees can't be bothered to even stand up...
  21. [Assistant Referees] Re: Pushed by player - my fault for being in field of play?

    Yes, and USA Rugby - correctly, for once - have been explicit about this. TJs are Match Officials.
    I did Discipline for a game where a Replacement was TJ. He was shoved, and then struck, by an...
  22. [Assistant Referees] Re: Pushed by player - my fault for being in field of play?

    Are the correct answers.
  23. [Assistant Referees] Re: Pushed by player - my fault for being in field of play?

    Right, and wrong.

    You aren't an AR unless appointed, so strictly, you have no role to play in stopping the foul play.
    However (at least over here) you are a Match Official and as such afforded...
  24. Replies
    24
    Views
    802

    Re: Time and injury

    Because the Law Book says so.


    [/LIST]


    [/LIST]
  25. Replies
    24
    Views
    802

    Re: Time and injury

    Wrong in law.
    Right in practice.
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4