Search:

@Marc - Yup, that why I said unless you've tee'd the ball up. All you've done up till now, is mark the place you're kicking/tapping from and put the ball on the ground at the mark. You've not...

Even now, unless you've tee'd the ball up on a tee. If you've just marked the Penalty Mark and put the ball on it, I can see no reason that up till then indicates any intentions. I'd allow the try in...

Offside line - From where the ball is thrown in. I guess you mean the that throwers team mates are infront of the thrower in terms of being further forward (closer to the opps DBL), in which case if...

I disagree slightly. The perfect parallel would be that the kicking team player was behind the catcher (eg inbetween the catcher and his DBL). When the ball is passed, would said defender be onside...

This is indeed the thing. In these contexts I'm a player, not an allocated ref. While I'm pretty junior and I know of at least 3 in my soc that still play, they're all considerably more senior than...

On a similar line. What if I'm playing and a ref allows this in a match I'm playing in. Should I intervene or would the ref not just think I'm trying to have one of their (the oppositions) players...

I have done so already. Lineout and QTI are a method of restarting play when the ball goes out of play. Why does the burden of proof lie with me. I could equally state the burden of proof is yours as...

But you've just said there is no offside!!

I'm sorry, I'm really not getting this CR. There is no such thing as a Quickly taken lineout. You have a QTI or a lineout. A QTI is a lineout that's taken quickly before a lineout can form.
...

Ok so if he was offside then we'd have a PK to red not a QTI to blue. So for the scenario above we have an onside blue player sprinting 40m+, making a tackle.

But as you said, putting that aside....

@CR - not sure I follow what scenario you're asking for.
The scenario in the OP. There good attacking pressure. Deep in blue territory so the player whos made the tackle (inside red 22m) has just...

At Pk as soon as the ball is tapped a player who was back 10 can come forward though. So he/she can tackle the BC/intercept a pass (if he's/she's fast enough)/charge down a kick. But he/she needs to...

But in the PK quick tap, the ball is live. A player who is back 10m can come forward to meet the BC and can tackle as soon as he gets there. The retiring player can engage when he gets 10m from the...

Ok so slightly different. I get tackled on the attacking 5m. I lose the ball in the process. The new BC runs 50m gets tackled. Ruck forms, ball comes out and passed away. I'm still trundling back...

Still not sure I get it. Is there a Law ref for this at all. Like I said, a QTI just seems like a lineout, taken quickly. Therefore other than the stated caveats regarding he throw etc. Offsides...

Yeah, I'd get really annoyed with this approach as a player. You'd be more lenient with an offence in the last 10 mins than the 1st 10 mins. Seems to be inconsistent to me. I ref from the word go the...

See, this I don't get. The ball's dead. There's no offside when the balls dead I get this. A QTI is just a quick method of taking a lineout. Therefore surely normal offside LO Laws should still...

@Dickie - lmao. It's not meant as an insult. It's just what we're called. Unless it's a Dundee FC fan. They call us DABs - Dirty Arab illegitimate Sons. We don't care though, they're the wee team...

I'm not quite sure I'm following this. Is there a Law ref, guidance, clarification on the WR site to state this. I would say (without any other input), that the tackler was offside from the throw (as...

Crossref and SimonSmith - I'm technically from Stirling (in Scotland). But I support Dundee UTD FC, if anyone needs to know, the DUFC fans are collectively known as the Arabs. There are many stories...

I'm a very new ref. 1st season, I've had 5 matches. So my experience may not be all that helpful. At the low levels I ref at I always just wait after the offence (except for bad high tackles, blow...

Every religion has this to some extent.
Christianity - Heaven
Islam - Paradise (Firdaws I think)
Judism - Shamayim
Hindu - Swarga Loka
Sikhism - Reincarnation to a higher Cast - Until Mukti is...

I've level 1 on both reffing and coaching (SRU land). Tend to be favouring reffing rather than coaching at least ATM. My local Club want me to coach the S1/S2s (Secondary School 1st and 2nd years)....

I had a Ladies Adult comp a few weeks ago. A lot of the ladies were having their 1st ever games. The organizers said that as it was a development comp, then they wanted game coaching rather than...

Does that mean we could also slot into the No 8 slot at the back of a scrum too :holysheep: