Search:

A QTI does not mean open play unless all the requirements have been met - not touched by someone else, taken from behind the LOT, thrown more than 5m infield, and thrown straight across the pitch or...

Mostly true, but there are some exceptions such as the 10m law.

Wot, "Mud, mud, glorious mud"? I think the drainage at Twickers has been improved in recent years.

There used to be some what Bill McLaren called "ill mannered booing" at GSTQ at Murrayfield...

Dickie, I think it is the event of the ball being played back into the game by a QTI that puts folks onside. The ball going into touch has the potential to create new offside lines if a lineout is...

I think I would escalate to a Free Kick.

Hope it goes well.

- - - Updated - - -



Good luck!

If you always ref with a TO3, then lucky you! If not, then you might have to consider sprint training :o)

I agree if he caught it it is play on, but if he did not catch it I htink you are back to looking at whether it made it to the plane of touch before he played it. If so, then he did not take it out...

On Saturday the ref in the game I was coaching was invited to walk through the tunnel, and did so.

Except that the moment he steps onto the iga, he is offside.

For me it depends on hat the ball carrying side are doing. If they are mostly stationery, then it is us it and possibly a scrum for accidental offside/ not using it. If they have started to drive...

I use a small (and sometimes waterproof) notebook - think they are called A7, and cards fit in the back, held in place with the elastic round the book. I find this helps as i record the time of each...

Looked to me like he dropped it and it was caught and kept off the ground by the player in front and his own hand which is why I think the KO was decided on.

But normally from a ko adv, being able to play without being under pressure is normally advantage gained.

Didds , for me, I take into account that YC if the team infringes again, but it depends on the next offence if it is a card. If I have warned a team, next pen here is yellow(I would not normally do...

But the only thing JP asked the TMO was if the rip by 21 was forward. I think it was but TMO and JP said not obviously so allowed the try.

But I think the question is should we?

From the description, what you did was fine. You had issued a warning and then escalated.

1 - No
2 - I think they count them up and use it as part of the scoring for club of the month

That's always been "any reason not to award a try" for me.

In Scotland the SRU want us to record all yellow through Whos the Ref - the appointing software, and the details required are pretty much the same as a red (and as Arabchief records above) and so it...

Cynical or repeated offence is foul play

But he had by this rather strange change to the protocol that requires an on-field decision first. What is that about? Why not be able to say to the TMO, not really sure if that was try, can you...

Perhaps, but Garces had asked to look at it, TMO said already done and not C&O forward. That should really have been then end of it, imo.

I've not watched the Japan game yet, but for me I wondered about Garces and the diallowed try - having allowed the run in he asked the TMO about the forward pass. TMO said they had aready looked at...