Search:

Type: Posts; User: crossref; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.30 seconds; generated 17 minute(s) ago.

  1. Replies
    30
    Views
    830

    Re: Jap v Sco - No Red Card?!?

    I understand the framework. I think the only thing that has gone wrong was introducing something new like this at the RWC
  2. Replies
    7
    Views
    52

    Re: End of Game - Did I get it Right?

    I think you were exactly right.
    Unfortunate for blue.
  3. Replies
    6
    Views
    205

    Re: RWC QF predictions

    You are correct

    Was that because Joubert got dropped though ..
  4. Replies
    6
    Views
    205

    Re: RWC QF predictions

    It's a nice idea - but last time the four refs with the QF did the following four games as well, I think.
  5. Replies
    7
    Views
    52

    Re: End of Game - Did I get it Right?

    I think you are technically correct. It's unlucky for blue to suffer the injury, but ...

    In some scenarios perhaps you could restart anyway - did the players know time had elapsed ? Was a it...
  6. Replies
    30
    Views
    830

    Re: Jap v Sco - No Red Card?!?

    I predict it will mean less concussion for ball carriers, more concussion for tacklers.

    Isn't that what happened when they trialled a not above the nipple line ? They had to stop the trial.
  7. Thread: YC return

    by crossref
    Replies
    46
    Views
    1,410

    Re: YC return

    BTW I am not raising it as a massive on field issue. Far from it, I made a quick call (can't take the kick) and we all moved on

    I raise it as a curiosity as I would be interested to know what the...
  8. Thread: YC return

    by crossref
    Replies
    46
    Views
    1,410

    Re: YC return

    I think you were definitely right, as in this case YC had alreadt expired when the try was scored

    In my case it still had a little time to run, so more questionable
  9. Replies
    35
    Views
    827

    [Law] Re: Penalty Kick at Goal Rules

    Of course


    The Quins one was very unusual in that the kick didn't hit the posts, or indeed the ground , it was directly caught by Marchant.

    aFAIK it was unique
  10. Replies
    30
    Views
    830

    Re: Jap v Sco - No Red Card?!?

    I kind of agree.

    But then there have been other tackles, equally accidental, where the referee might have similarly strayed from the framework .. but those guys got a RC and then suspended.
    ...
  11. Thread: YC return

    by crossref
    Replies
    46
    Views
    1,410

    Re: YC return

    One is u17 the other is adult
    One had a player from both teams in bin, so your decision won't disadvantage one team and advantage the other , as was the case in mine
    Your YC was about niggles and...
  12. Thread: YC return

    by crossref
    Replies
    46
    Views
    1,410

    Re: YC return

    I think that's a very very different scenario.

    Even so, if it was me then when the time was up I would let them on .
  13. Replies
    30
    Views
    830

    Re: Jap v Sco - No Red Card?!?

    IInterestingly the Framework DOES specifcally include head-to-head contaxct



    RED CARD

    Shoulder charge (no arms tackle) to the head or neck of the ball carrier, and mitigation is not applied...
  14. Thread: YC return

    by crossref
    Replies
    46
    Views
    1,410

    Re: YC return

    Yes and even at my lowly level I know perfectly well that I can get away with either decision ... But I would like to know what is the correct decision .. as that's the one I will give , if I can.
  15. Thread: YC return

    by crossref
    Replies
    46
    Views
    1,410

    Re: YC return

    What if it says 31 ? They have 90s to make the kick right.

    What if there was a big stadium clock so everyone could see the time?

    Is it ok that some of your YC last 9 minutes and others last...
  16. Replies
    30
    Views
    830

    Re: Jap v Sco - No Red Card?!?

    You do need to read the framework ! Otherwise you must have no idea why decisions are being made the way they are.
  17. Replies
    35
    Views
    827

    [Law] Re: Penalty Kick at Goal Rules

    At a Quins game last season Marcus Smith kicked onto a strong headwind and the ball caught the wind and fell down just short of the cross bar, where it was caught by the chasing Joe Marchant, who...
  18. Replies
    30
    Views
    830

    Re: Jap v Sco - No Red Card?!?

    Tbh I have some sympathy will Aki who I think was to some extent an unlucky victim of the framework. His case will be considerably helped by BOK's decision today which (as long as WR don't disavow...
  19. Replies
    35
    Views
    827

    [Law] Re: Penalty Kick at Goal Rules

    I once had this happen.

    The captain said to me he was choosing a shot at posts.

    Moments later the scrum half, who hadn't heard him, tapped and ran.

    I brought them back and said they had to...
  20. Replies
    35
    Views
    827

    [Law] Re: Penalty Kick at Goal Rules

    he he -- i mean Clarification 2 of 2006, of course. As discussed above
  21. Replies
    35
    Views
    827

    [Law] Re: Penalty Kick at Goal Rules

    I think you are making the Law up as you go !
    The 2015 amendment does give you a justification for awarding the throw to the non-kicking team, but there is no Law justifiction for not allowing gain...
  22. Replies
    136
    Views
    6,059

    [RWC] Re: How are the RWC refs doing so far ?

    you are talking about last week's game, beladonna and I were talking about today's game
  23. Replies
    30
    Views
    830

    Re: Jap v Sco - No Red Card?!?

    it will be very interesting to see how that goes.
  24. Replies
    30
    Views
    830

    Re: Jap v Sco - No Red Card?!?

    I have a feeling WR will mark that as a critical error, at the same time as most of the rugby world think the result he arrived at was fair
  25. Replies
    30
    Views
    830

    Re: Jap v Sco - No Red Card?!?

    For me he probably ignored the letter of the framework .. I was expecting a mechanical RC ...

    He decided there was no foul play . I agree with that. But the framework seems to say we card players...
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4