Search:

Type: Posts; User: didds; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.11 seconds; generated 33 minute(s) ago.

  1. Re: Munster vs Southern Kings 14 February 2020. - Yellow card

    so is the video evidence the same case as discussed in the OP? There is a suggestion above/previously that it isnt.

    If it is the sasme then the cideo soesnt seem to match the O)P's description of...
  2. Re: Munster vs Southern Kings 14 February 2020. - Yellow card

    yes


    and when its > 2 and player X wants to try and remove his TEAMATE from the fracas that is as bad? is that what I am reading here? Just wnat to be sure?

    didds

    - - - Updated - - -
  3. Re: Munster vs Southern Kings 14 February 2020. - Yellow card

    what wheen there are several... players shouldnt stand aside and try and stop their teammates ?

    didds
  4. Re: Munster vs Southern Kings 14 February 2020. - Yellow card

    ????????????

    The OP says

    "Red 20 (openside flanker) runs back 20m to get involved. While trying to drag a teammate out of the brawl he got an elbow in the head for his trouble."

    ...
  5. Re: Munster vs Southern Kings 14 February 2020. - Yellow card

    so he shouldnt have tried to prevent his own team mate from further escalation of the melee? (from the OP description)


    didds
  6. Replies
    20
    Views
    445

    [Tackle] Re: Not really a tackle but a slide..

    As we cant read his mind I'd question the " or taking him out" suggestion. sometimes shit happens. That doesnt not make it dangeropus of course - and while allegedly refs shouldnt take intention...
  7. Replies
    19
    Views
    252

    Re: 22 Drop Out - Not taken properly

    sounds familiar...
  8. Replies
    20
    Views
    445

    [Tackle] Re: Not really a tackle but a slide..

    except one is a tackle on the ball carrier and the other is the ball carrier on a defnder - a hand off is a better comparison.

    didds
  9. Replies
    19
    Views
    252

    Re: 22 Drop Out - Not taken properly

    We've covered actual game footage of this albeit the underarm toss to the running player was a deliberate ploy...

    didds

    - - - Updated - - -



    and sometimes people don't hear the whistle...
  10. Replies
    20
    Views
    445

    [Tackle] Re: Not really a tackle but a slide..

    Sympathies with both players.

    PK, dangerous play, finger wag to be careful going forward.

    didds
  11. Replies
    18
    Views
    473

    [Tackle] Re: Pulling through at the tackle

    I guess if blue has the ball in his hands there is not contact OVER the ball. Instead its contact with a ball carrier ie an attempted tackle.

    didds
  12. Replies
    15
    Views
    405

    [Law] Re: Windy days. What can happen?

    I'm sure it would be counted as taken back in, and I do appreciate your attempt to rationalise it - but in your example there are two distinct actions... it's not the 22 drop out that is the action...
  13. Replies
    15
    Views
    405

    [Law] Re: Windy days. What can happen?

    or simpler (?)

    22 D/O crosses 22 and is blown back inside the same 22 where the defemdoig team kick direct to touch.

    Taken back in, no ground?

    didds
  14. Thread: Food for thought

    by didds
    Replies
    3
    Views
    180

    Re: Food for thought

    i might have said at one time its possibly more because SA refs ref other SA domestic matches which emjans SA players arev more in tune with the way SA refs interpret and blkow the laws... ("SA" is...
  15. Thread: women's rugby

    by didds
    Replies
    27
    Views
    683

    Re: women's rugby

    Don't they use a 4.5 sized ball already?

    didds
  16. Replies
    28
    Views
    819

    [Law] Re: Quick tap penalty

    i get what yoru saying.

    But equally the retreating defender HAS to be somewhere.

    didds
  17. Replies
    25
    Views
    603

    [Junior] Re: U14 Rugby - Lineout

    Come in late here - sorry.

    As a coach Id interpret that to mean uncontested throw and catch. But its all "ON" after that.

    Otherwsie team A could be in its own 22, catch a lineout and...
  18. Replies
    28
    Views
    560

    Re: New Front Row logic tree

    well, maybe :-) Not that I'd EVER condone such a situation, though also i suppose when I was coaching seniors I was still registered as a player and in such situations was down as a the FR...
  19. Replies
    28
    Views
    560

    Re: New Front Row logic tree

    in experience then... do you guys find that teams that cant start with a FR replacement just cry off? Or do their oppo cry off as they now have "the win" and need not risk injury in what woud be a...
  20. Replies
    28
    Views
    560

    Re: New Front Row logic tree

    I would suggest that is downb to match regulations eg cup, league.

    If its a frriendly and the np FR replacements team is told before kick off "youve altready lost the match" they may well just go...
  21. Replies
    28
    Views
    819

    [Law] Re: Quick tap penalty

    Totally fine by me.

    what is (s)he otherwise supposed to do? run alongside the BC until the BC scores 50m later?

    didds
  22. Thread: Offside by QTI

    by didds
    Replies
    111
    Views
    3,818

    [Line out] Re: Offside by QTI

    I have grreat sympathies for you all on this subject.

    Meanwhile players, coaches etc still have to play to some sort of vague plan.

    So dont be surprised when player X stands still when in...
  23. Replies
    252
    Views
    13,419

    Re: Where are you this weekend - 2019-20

    Murrayfield!
  24. Thread: Six Nations 2020

    by didds
    Replies
    30
    Views
    1,097

    Re: Six Nations 2020

    gotcha. yes indeed. I was directly discussing the try in question etc - but even then the player could have inadvertently headed it (possibly etc)

    didds
  25. Replies
    25
    Views
    1,066

    [Law] Re: Wales Italy 6N 2020; was Biggar offside?

    Good spot.

    Id say no ruck, so tackle not through the gate. There is contact "over the ball" bit at least one player (blue) is not on his feet - he is the tackler that has "inadevertently" fallen...
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4