Search:

Type: Posts; User: frenchie851; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3

Search: Search took 0.07 seconds; generated 1 minute(s) ago.

  1. Replies
    17
    Views
    1,295

    Re: Quins v Exeter - Fortunate?

    Yes, he has admitted the PT was an error. It wasn't said what the decision should have been. Barnes said the scrum was 'crabbing'.
  2. Replies
    22
    Views
    1,667

    [Tackle] Re: Pulling through at the tackle

    I agree with Dickie

    If it get very, very messy with lots of bodies on the floor and ball is not playable just blow whistle and restart with a scrum.
  3. Replies
    28
    Views
    1,444

    [Law] Re: Quick tap penalty

    I got my question answered then there were a few other 'what ifs' thrown up and they have also helped me better under stand the scenario as a whole.

    Second year in reffing as much discussion about...
  4. Replies
    28
    Views
    1,444

    [Law] Re: Quick tap penalty

    If the ball carrier hadn't travelled the 10m and the pursuing player prevented him from passing to a team mate then I would have given a pen.

    If the ball carrier had travelled 10m then I would...
  5. Replies
    28
    Views
    1,444

    [Law] Re: Quick tap penalty

    I should have said the reason I mentioned this was because after speaking to another ref he suggested that maybe the tackler should have 'got onside' before making a tackle.

    My thought process was...
  6. Replies
    28
    Views
    1,444

    [Law] Re: Quick tap penalty

    He didn't reduce the ball carriers options as the ball carrier had chosen to run off and isolate himself. Other players from his team were very slow on the uptake and there was no one in support of...
  7. Replies
    28
    Views
    1,444

    [Law] Re: Quick tap penalty

    Do you mean if the tackle happened 10m from the original mark of the penalty?
  8. [Law] Re: Penalty and tackler not back 10m - Yellow Card?

    I've given a yellow card for this but only when it has been in the red zone and the tackler is denying space.
  9. Replies
    28
    Views
    1,444

    [Law] Quick tap penalty

    Blue player takes penalty quickly. Pink player (at a breakdown and inline with the mark) follows the ball carrier and ensures that the ball carrier travels 10 meters and then tackles the ball...
  10. Replies
    96
    Views
    4,570

    [Law] Re: Knock on into the dead ball area.

    From the description in my original post I would now give a scrum.

    If the ball was knocked on in goal.... I would give a scrum.


    From the original post I sensed I had made a mistake and just...
  11. Replies
    20
    Views
    1,132

    [Law] Re: Deliberate knock forward

    just a practical question, does the buffering on this website take an age for anyone else? I have tried to use this on multiple devices on different internet connections and it is always a bit crap!
  12. Replies
    96
    Views
    4,570

    [Law] Re: Knock on into the dead ball area.

    Thinking on my feet and not reading an law before answering I think I would give a 22.

    My reasoning for this is that when the ball is taken into in-goal I always think about who took it into in...
  13. Replies
    96
    Views
    4,570

    [Law] Re: Knock on into the dead ball area.

    I didn't mention who the ref was in the game I was watching (because I didn't want it to affect the discussion) but was Owens, so I am happy to go with "he got it right and I got it wrong".

    I do...
  14. Replies
    9
    Views
    617

    [Kit] Re: High Leg boots Quins v Clermont

    I agree to be fair but when I first saw them I thought of how I knew of the old regulations against it.

    To be fair I never understood why you weren't allowed the toe stud! In the old days did...
  15. Replies
    9
    Views
    617

    [Kit] Re: High Leg boots Quins v Clermont

    Unfortunately not, they are crap flimsy things not the high ankle leather boots that provide protection and support like they used to.
  16. Replies
    38
    Views
    2,234

    [Law] Re: Place of Conversion kick

    I think I try to come across as reasonable when reffing, I don't think you are going to get an objection from the players and captain behind the sticks so allowing them to take it out wider is a...
  17. Replies
    96
    Views
    4,570

    [Law] Re: Knock on into the dead ball area.

    OB.... That's cleared it up for me.

    sub law (f). Doesn't allow vantage to be played.

    During the game I played advantage then I saw it dotted down and in my head I thought "why not a 22?"
    ...
  18. Replies
    270
    Views
    17,663

    Re: Where are you this weekend - 2019-20

    How did this one go Phil? No repeat injury?
  19. Replies
    96
    Views
    4,570

    [Law] Knock on into the dead ball area.

    I was watching a game today, if the attacking team knock the ball on into the dead ball area, defensive team then touch it down, would you give the option of the knock on or 22?

    I have been giving...
  20. Replies
    9
    Views
    617

    [Kit] Re: High Leg boots Quins v Clermont

    They are American Football cleats, I've played both sports so recognised them straight away.. A lot of the players had those ones from the link above, because our team were The Steelers we wore black...
  21. [Law] Re: summary of law changes, proposals and trials ?

    The area I am confused on it the the tackle height. They did one trial on the tackle height being chest height and it was found that reducing the tackle height cause more head injuries? (I think...
  22. [Golden Oldies] Re: Reports on Referee post-game on WhosTheRef

    I listen to feedback from coaches, log it and move on. If a coach with an axe to grind gives you feedback that you don't agree with then move on. If a succession of coaches give you the same feedback...
  23. Replies
    43
    Views
    3,572

    [Tackle] Re: Open play, non-maul

    I think we have seen the most resonable response give a scrum but then warn captain that you don't want to see it again. Good preventative refereeing.

    If you are questioned after the game by the...
  24. Replies
    5
    Views
    417

    [Scrum] Re: Back row angle at scrum

    If the flankers actions are causing the Prop to not drive straight and in at an angle just penalise the Prop. It is up to the prop to tell the flanker to stop what he is doing so that the prop...
  25. Replies
    35
    Views
    2,149

    [Tackle] Re: Tackle Release

    unless he called it to be a ruck all ready then when the red player goes to ground and blue is still holding the ball red should let go.
Results 1 to 25 of 69
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3