PDA

View Full Version : Ball over plane of touch but blown back in



breako
17-01-19, 20:01
It's a windy day. The ball is kicked over the plane of touch, doesn't touch anything and is then blown back in. Is it in touch?

Thanks

Flish
17-01-19, 21:01
No, I think, in law, and practically speaking as chances are I couldn’t be that precise anyway!

Decorily
17-01-19, 21:01
It's a windy day. The ball is kicked over the plane of touch, doesn't touch anything and is then blown back in. Is it in touch?

Thanks

No...play on.

If you are TJing or ARing don't get caught by sticking the flag up too soon! !

Taff
17-01-19, 21:01
It's a windy day. The ball is kicked over the plane of touch, doesn't touch anything and is then blown back in. Is it in touch?
No. The ball isn't in touch until


If it is being carried, the ball carrier touches the touch line or the ground beyond it or
If it is loose, it touches the touch line or the ground beyond it.

didds
18-01-19, 09:01
It's a windy day. The ball is kicked over the plane of touch, doesn't touch anything and is then blown back in. Is it in touch?

Thanks

Nope. Play on.

didds

Phil E
18-01-19, 10:01
As someone who has fallen foul of this I can definitely say "don't blow your whistle until the ball touches something in touch!".

I once blew for touch after a ball kicked into touch from a penalty went about 30 yards over the line, over the heads of all the spectators.
Only to see it get caught by a gust of wind just as I blew, and bend back into play where it was caught by a defender. Half the players played on, half stopped.

Never did that again!

Marc Wakeham
18-01-19, 11:01
Me too!

Thunderhorse1986
18-01-19, 12:01
As someone who has fallen foul of this I can definitely say "don't blow your whistle until the ball touches something in touch!".

I once blew for touch after a ball kicked into touch from a penalty went about 30 yards over the line, over the heads of all the spectators.
Only to see it get caught by a gust of wind just as I blew, and bend back into play where it was caught by a defender. Half the players played on, half stopped.

Never did that again!

Restart scrum to the catcher's team?

Phil E
18-01-19, 12:01
Restart scrum to the catcher's team?

I tried to call play on, some did, some didn't. It was carnage for a few seconds.

On reflection I should have blown up, apologised and let them kick the penalty to touch again.

Big learning point.