• Referee Rankings after the Pool Stages

    Well the ratings have been made and the table makes quite interesting reading.

    Paddy O'Brien and the rest of the iRB Referee team must be very pleased with themselves, although our tables ranks the referees, all have performed very well, and while someone has to come bottom, it's not been because they have refereed badly, but it's due to the exceptional refereeing of their colleagues.

    So here are the tables, you can see we have highlighted the Northern & Southern Hemisphere referees, as well as making the top score in each column bold.




    We know the Quarter Final appointments come out today, and if our members are correct the four referees that should be in the middle for these these will be Poite, Joubert, Barnes with a choice between Owens & Kaplan as the 4th/5th place (depending on what table you look at).

    Some people have speculated that as the Qtr final draw has split the hemispheres there will be 2 NH Refs and 2 SH refs. If this is the case Kaplan will get the nod ahead of Owens.

    The interesting part will be if the iRB put the Refs in their own hemisphere, or the other hemisphere. There are 2 ways to look at this, if the referee does the game from their hemisphere, the game may flow better because the teams will be used to that style of play, however it may also bring in (totally unfounded) allegations of bias.

    To put my money where my mouth is I think that if we are right in our ranks the appointments will be:

    NZ v Argentina - Kaplan
    Eng v Fra - Joubert
    South Africa v Australia - Barnes
    Ireland v Wales - Poite

    However, I don't believe we will have been rating exactly like the iRB, and my prediction for actual appointments are:

    NZ v Argentina - Barnes
    Eng v Fra - Rolland
    South Africa v Australia - Lawrence
    Ireland v Wales - Joubert

    We'll soon find out.
    Comments 3 Comments
    1. Speedbird's Avatar
      Speedbird -
      2 out of 4 pretty good going!
    1. Jenko's Avatar
      Jenko -
      Quote Originally Posted by Speedbird View Post
      2 out of 4 pretty good going!
      E v F ref Steve Walsh
      Joubert W v I
      Bryce Lawrence - Aus v SA
      Owens - NZ v Arg

      according to Brian Moore.
    1. Robert Burns's Avatar
      Robert Burns -
      Yes, announced on IRB website a while ago.

      2 out of 4 ain't bad.
  • Recent Activity Widget

    CrouchTPEngage

    Seat-belt tackle now legal?

    Thread Starter: CrouchTPEngage

    Just watching Leicester Quins where the commentary team made a big thing about the seat belt tackle no longer being a penalty offence. Can someone please point me.at the clarification in law or guidelines as I must have missed.a refs meeting where this was discussed. From the commentary, 'the...

    Last Post By: dave_clark 2 Hours Ago Go to last post
    ctrainor

    Players told to respect referees as abuse soars

    Thread Starter: ctrainor

    Players told to respect referees as abuse soars http://digitaleditions.telegraph.co.uk/data/806/reader/reader.html?social#!preferred/0/package/806/pub/806/page/124/article/247214 What do people think about this? I had a couple of games last month that made me question why I'm reffing at all...

    Last Post By: Zebra1922 2 Hours Ago Go to last post
    belladonna

    Wal v Aus: Coach Verbally Attacks Officials

    Thread Starter: belladonna

    Looks like the Aussie coach might be facing a ban?

    Last Post By: Zebra1922 2 Hours Ago Go to last post
    smeagol

    Position at tap FK/penalty

    Thread Starter: smeagol

    When a side is awarded a PK/FK and are going to tap, assuming it's not a quick tap and you have time to get into position, what is the best position to take relative to the attacking side? If I see pods forming, I usually try to set up 1-2m directly behind the player taking the tap so as to be...

    Last Post By: Dickie E 15 Hours Ago Go to last post
  • Twitter