• Please bear with us. We have moved to a new provider, and some images and icons are not working correctly. We are working hard to fix this

Right decision the wrong way

SimonSmith


Referees in Australia
Staff member
Last night was the second weekend of the season for us here in sunny Alice.

A rarity in my game - contested scrums. 5 v 5, but nonetheless scrums.

There had been a bit of creaking and groaning, and I had noticed that the last two, when Green had the put in, there was a bit of wheel through White's left shoulder. I'm suspicious, me; so when I heard the White Hooker yelling "Left" as we were setting up, I scooted round to his TH side to watch the feet.

Ball comes in, and the TH walks sideways, creating the wheel and his opposite number falling in. Not the easiest PK of the night, but close.

Had a debrief with the Coach and the TH afterwards. "You might want to change the call" was my advice, which was greeted with bemusement. I explained what I had heard and seen, at which point I got laughed at.

"He's got no idea, the hooker. He's actually calling 'lift' "

I admit, I felt a bit deflated that my acute observational skills had, in fact, been quite obtuse.

So, what decisions have you got right the wrong way?
 
Nice story, but I'm also curious what the hooker's intentional call of "lift" was for... that doesn't sound like it's within the laws either!
 
Take some note of the calls -but trust your own judgement; "Push straight, and push Level" and I'll not blow the whistle.

It's a pushing/hooking contest: not a wheeling contest!
 
Take some note of the calls -but trust your own judgement; "Push straight, and push Level" and I'll not blow the whistle.

It's a pushing/hooking contest: not a wheeling contest!
though obviously wheeling can be done totally legally via pushing (eg not stepping and driving, or pulling). Wheeling is not inherrently always illegal.
 
'Natural' wheeling tends to be slow, the scrum remains stable and the players fully bound- and is not illegal. When I see players trying to wheel deliberately -often much quicker and destabilising the scrum - then I become involved.
 
Back
Top