Search:

This.

I was wonderign if in fact the whole coaching approach was "we'll risk a RC". Which doesnt make any sense to me, outside of cynical plays in the last 10 minutes (im not suggesting that is...

I saw Bath v Glos. I didn't see Leics v Wasps so Missed out on that fun!

B v G - red card each side. one for a forearm smash as ball carrier (G), the other for the head clash in a stand up...

;-) ;-) ;-)

It could - and as i said in my post quoted/followed from



Was it blue just fraffing around? Or red standing slightly offset at blue's put in so blue have to move to get opimal/correct head...

well that would see halpenny RC after two attempts by him to tackle then. Indeed.

This. 100%.

for if nothing else jumping to avoid a tackle form behind has a very very very very very low risk of dangerous play involved.
Jumping to avoid a tackle from right in front ie head...

And the FK gets taken as a scrum and we are bacvk to square one. Unless of course eventually becasue it happens to often you end up with a PK for deleiberate law breaking.

but you had be pretty...

That's a FK that can be of course taken as a scrum? becasue after all, a FK on your own 10m line is other wise just useless.

I thouht it was. maybe i have the worng game? Cant say I CBA to watch the entire game again to try and find it - LOL

as was oft debated at the time. Watch the Ire v Fra game - (think it was that one?) somebody jumped to catch a ball that had already boiunced - and won a pk for beign tackled in the air. was the...

Or rather than clip the tackler's head with the boot, does the tackler just headbutt his boot? Seeing as May was already well past the point of tackle by that time?

purely devils...

Yup. Agree CR. All I recall is the ref speaking to the TMO seeking clarification on a head clash.

id guess mauul from lineout still on the LoR so backlines stay back 10m ?

we can debate all we like buit until WR agree asnd act its is no more than that.

Meanwhile... if scrums werre blown in fullm accorance with the alws a deal of the stupidity wood disappear. when...

Id read that tio mean the "player" is not the ball carrier

Id agree but its clear that the twitterato disagree with us.

didds

PS Im Farrel fan FTR

- - - Updated - - -

Meanwhiel if you think this To4 had a poor game, have a gander at India v Engl;and 2nd test day 1 and the bat pad DRS appeal wheer the 3rd umpire gave up after there was no bat nick onto the pad,...

ISTR they were so ficussed on a possible head clasj - that it wsnt - they'd either forgotten any other issue, or hadnt even considered any late charge etc

didds

what does reg 15 )IIRC) say?

google regulation 15 rFU ?

you guys will have a definitive answer but maybe the solution would have been for #10 to not drop the goal in the first place, even if it required red captain shouting at him.

and his decisioons allowed england to win comofrtably with a session and a half to go...

Not quite following your thread here - what drop goal would they be spurning? One they made in open play and the PK became apparent AFTERWARDS? Im not aware of any law or protocol that would afford...

India v England 0400-1100ish C4.

even though the ball is clearly moving upfield albeit its trajectory as seen from above is on an arc ?

the stationary point may be one player while everybody else circles around them.

For...

Id let it be there choice and if they chose to do so id worry and be proud etc.

Same if they got on a horse. Or a mortor cycle. Or downhill cycling. Or free basing. Or extreme ironing.

they...