Search:

Type: Posts; User: OB..; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.25 seconds.

  1. Replies
    33
    Views
    1,365

    [Law] Re: Jumping or Diving Clarification required

    I think your view is inappropriately legalistic, and shows no empathy for the game.
  2. Replies
    33
    Views
    1,365

    [Law] Re: Jumping or Diving Clarification required

    If the tackle is preventing the ball carrier from reaching out to score, then forcing the tackler to release is demanding that he gives away a score - which seems inequitable.
  3. Replies
    33
    Views
    1,365

    [Law] Re: Jumping or Diving Clarification required

    That is my "Mexican Stand-off" situation. I recommend a quick whistle and a 5-metre attacking scrum.
  4. Replies
    33
    Views
    1,365

    [Law] Re: Jumping or Diving Clarification required

    The basic actions of hurdling a tackler and diving for the line are different. The former raises a distinct likelihood of boot meeting head when they are travelling in different directions. The...
  5. Thread: Danny Care Try

    by OB..
    Replies
    30
    Views
    1,329

    [In-goal] Re: Danny Care Try

    14.1 A tackle can take place anywhere in the field of play.
    "Field of play" should obviously be "playing area" (see Definitions). We have all seen tackles take place in in-goal - how else to stop...
  6. Replies
    75
    Views
    6,277

    Re: Bath Vs Wasps 8.1.21

    (Times report)
  7. Replies
    46
    Views
    3,438

    [Law] Re: What's your worst nightmare?

    There's an (apocryphal?) story about a referee who awarded a PK, and when the captain started to complain, he marched them back 10m. And again. And again. At which point the other captain said...
  8. Replies
    75
    Views
    6,277

    Re: Bath Vs Wasps 8.1.21

    Agreed.
  9. Replies
    75
    Views
    6,277

    Re: Bath Vs Wasps 8.1.21

    I am not sure it had that imprimatur, but it was certainly what I advised. However I did not insist if the ref made things clear anyway.
  10. Replies
    46
    Views
    3,438

    [Law] Re: What's your worst nightmare?

    I turned up at a club for a 2nd XV game, only to be informed that they did not have a second pitch so they used a local council pitch. "It's easy to find - it's right behind the Primary School." I...
  11. Replies
    36
    Views
    2,274

    [Tackle] Re: missed something since lockdown

    Well said, didds.
  12. Thread: Greetings

    by OB..
    Replies
    4
    Views
    607

    Re: Greetings

    Ditto. (both)
  13. Replies
    24
    Views
    2,455

    Re: 5 worst ref decision

    I have previously disputed #3 on this site. Traille was being tackled as he passed the ball and was falling forward. I produced a still that shows his outstretched hand is in front of the ball just...
  14. Replies
    33
    Views
    2,286

    Re: Where are you this weekend 20/21?

    If you're a bridge player, you might have noticed that Joe Biden has bid and made a very tricky "NO TRUMP" contract.
  15. Replies
    15
    Views
    1,526

    Re: Disgraceful disciplinary decision

    "Contrary to good sportsmanship" is a catch-all provision and can therefore cover a wide range of actions. Some will be really serious (but not covered elsewhere), some trivial.
  16. Replies
    33
    Views
    2,286

    Re: Where are you this weekend 20/21?

    Having just received my first vaccination, I have decided to stay at home. Again.
    (There is no local rugby anyway ...).
  17. Re: Nigel Owens - Diolch yn fawr iawn (Thank you very much)

    What did he do if any player "quipped" back at him?
  18. Replies
    10
    Views
    1,167

    [Law] Re: Pushing a ball carrier

    If it's not forbidden, then it must be allowed (note the catch-all in 9.11)
  19. Replies
    12
    Views
    1,014

    Re: Steve Thompson et al

    There is a legal precept "Volenti non fit injuria", which basically says "if you accepted the normal risk of doing something, you cannot blame anybody else if you get hurt". The applicability in...
  20. Replies
    61
    Views
    4,682

    Re: Biggar Taken in Air?

    ... but impracticable.
  21. Replies
    61
    Views
    4,682

    Re: Biggar Taken in Air?

    Marginal knock-on? Marginal offside? etc.
  22. Replies
    61
    Views
    4,682

    Re: Biggar Taken in Air?

    Perhaps it should be agreed that if A is waiting to catch the ball, and B jumps to try and get there first, B is at fault if he lands on A. All B can do is flatten A as he makes the catch.
  23. Replies
    14
    Views
    901

    Re: When is advantage over

    My guideline has always been that if a kick is taken under advantage that was clearly voluntary, then the kicker lives with the outcome. Advantage is not just a free shot where you can come back if...
  24. Replies
    14
    Views
    901

    Re: When is advantage over

    They could have opted for a scrum anyway. How far back was the penalty spot?
  25. Replies
    14
    Views
    901

    Re: When is advantage over

    If the kick was taken under pressure, then it might be deemed no advantage.
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4