Search:

Your position is confused - you say he’s not taking the P but next sentence you acknowledge he’s trying to be witty. He is talking absolute nonsense that’s the point.

This interview made national...

In the linked interview he’s taking the P.....

A number of us reached exactly the same view point as Dickie......

This isn’t a refs’ site surely it’s a site about referring?

It was an honest question, politely asked by a new poster. A polite answer surely would have sufficed. Norman I hope you stay around and contribute to the site and hopefully we can all broaden our...

I was at the match - and think some of the boos were caused by ‘lap’ of honour - when he was lifted up he got a French regional flag and the tricolour and wrap it round his shoulders before parading...

Talking of Ian he’s been very quiet since last Saturday......

Think he’s got it right - lands on arm / shoulder.

Equally think that he’s going to have a ‘robust’ debrief after that performance

Angle I saw was side / arm

But the lack of clarity confirms the bravery/stupidity of not going upstairs

Does he not land on his side?

Bit 100% agree why not go upstairs - odd.

Australia deploying the old reverse psychology.

Oh come off it - it’s the oldest trick in the book - say nothing rude but say you be bringing it up via the formal channels.

You’ve had the wool pulled over your eyes if you don’t think he’s...

Isn’t that the type of quote that normally gets you hot under the collar when Eddie Jones makes them....

I think you’re placing far too much on that one decision - which I don’t think is an unreasonable call.

Perhaps look at how your team could improve (tackling would be a good starting point for...

Good ploy - badly actioned. I said to my mate in the pub they’re running this - he was over exaggerating the signal.

And you March them 10ms they now have a FK outside the 22......

That's a false equivalence.

A fairer one would be - as you are putting your glass of red wine down on the table (successfully) at the moment it rests on the table and the fingers are still in...

Well he was holding it, didn’t let go of it and then touched it down. There was no knock on, no drop, no fumble.

For me that’s an excellent bit of skill that hasn’t been rewarded. I’d given the...

His aim was to ground the ball - he achieved that aim as he intended - how has he lost control?

JP is a good ref. But today, on reflection, won’t be amongst his career highlights.

The bath player going off injured tripping over the physio bag as play was allowed to carry on too close to an...

More evidence of anti Irish bias by Wayne Barnes...........

A good ref no doubt.

I think this was not one for his highlight reel.

The try (assuming he gives it for Hogg’s second go) is a poor decesion. It’s scored after the whistle and is clearly a...

Not odd at all - it was knocked on and Watson doesn't ground it - in goal or in field... (to be fair once I saw the KO the rest was kind of irrelevant).

Let's not disappear down a rabbit hole. ...

I disagree - the highlights on the 6. Nations app show it better.

The grounding is fine - Watson is short of the goal line

It looks like a knock on in the air off green 15 to me - but hey ho better side won no gripes.