Punching fighting. If punches miss, is that not a red then ?

[didds]

what - 2 weeks ban rather than 4 then ? ;-)

didds

[damo]

what - 2 weeks ban rather than 4 then ? ;-)

didds

Possibly, but I was going more for the idea that a YC more often fits the crime of attempted punching than a RC does.

I think it always depends upon the facts of the incident. One-size-fits-all pronouncements are not the best way to go imo.