All blacks third try tackled or not?

[ctrainor]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KBPBA4cbBIQ
about 3.40 into this clip does anyone think caleb clarke was tackled?
I do

[Christy]

All good for me .
Are you talking about yellow 15 ,, close to 22 .
Not held for me & play on

[Decorily]

It was a tackle for me....having watched it a couple of times.
In the heat of battle I would probably have allowed play continue!

[Marc Wakeham]

Held and brought to ground, for me.

[RugbyHippo]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KBPBA4cbBIQ
about 3.40 into this clip does anyone think caleb clarke was tackled?
I do

Agree
So he should have let go of the ball, he did not.
Do you think he should have been penalized for it?

[Marc Wakeham]

Agree
So he should have let go of the ball, he did not.
Do you think he should have been penalized for it?

It them's the facts, yes he should.

[Balones]

A tackle for me. Frames 4.11 and 4.12. If we expect a tackler to release immediately then we must reward them for doing so after they have made a good tackle. Otherwise they end up hanging on for a bit longer. And also get penalised?

[RugbyHippo]

It them's the facts, yes he should.

How about materiality? Aus is 1-2 meter away so not in credible position to compete IMO.

[Decorily]

How about materiality? Aus is 1-2 meter away so not in credible position to compete IMO.

Seriously?

[Marc Wakeham]

How about materiality? Aus is 1-2 meter away so not in credible position to compete IMO.

The material effect of releasing the ball and having to get up and then play the ball again. The tackler is there and other player ON THEIR FEET are close enough to beat him to the ball.

Clearly and obviously material.