Search results

  1. SimonSmith

    Outcome-deciding PT with clock in the red

    D2 regional already on the pathway? I don't think that's a universal - and I speak from experience. Depending on what else is going on the region, a referee can simply be the safest pair of hands around. I'm loathe to bag the guy based solely on the video clip I watched - the bit at the end. I...
  2. SimonSmith

    Bath vs Saracens

    A point that Stephen Jones made more recently - in about 2000! Midnight Rugby was the bookm Ithink.
  3. SimonSmith

    When do your grounds get closed?

    We play in the summer. In Alice Springs. We got rained on once this season.
  4. SimonSmith

    Outcome-deciding PT with clock in the red

    I couldn't see the offence, so have to trust that the ref was sighted. I wonder how the debrief went,
  5. SimonSmith

    Boot selection & sizing

    I only referee on very firm ground, so I use Brooks Trail Runners- snug. Back in the US it was Asics Gel - my preferred was their old Lacrosse boot.
  6. SimonSmith

    Restarting the second half with a penalty.

    I probably need longer at HT than the teams. We have unlimited interchanges because heat, and I need a sit down, a drink and a chancce to cool down in the aircon.
  7. SimonSmith

    Where are you this weekend - 2023/24?

    I shall be at home, feet up, large drinks, watching the games on the telly.
  8. SimonSmith

    Ire v Sco Ball Held Up After Maul

    On your description, Blue 12 is legal and the ref got it right. No maul in-goal. 16.16.c
  9. SimonSmith

    Law reference for foul play penalties priority

    "You - last man in" or "You - first man in"
  10. SimonSmith

    Where are you this weekend - 2023/24?

    Are you on exchange to Mercury?
  11. SimonSmith

    Law reference for foul play penalties priority

    In days of yore, the guidance was "penalize someone - do NOT let the players immediately get back to a phase where they can hit each other"
  12. SimonSmith

    Law reference for foul play penalties priority

    Up until the punch, it was going to be: PK against Red 14, plus a card. Reverse for Blue coming in. Reverse again for Red 3. Third man in is always at risk.
  13. SimonSmith

    Driven to ground in ruck

    You have done well Padawan.
  14. SimonSmith

    Where are you this weekend - 2023/24?

    This is good. In Alice, we're on radios the whole time. Middle man is vox - broadcasting all the time. AR's are on buttons - but the buttons are big things, so not at all fiddly. We use Ref Audio Pro, and they are excellent.
  15. SimonSmith

    Driven to ground in ruck

    You should take up refereeing Didds! Exactly the answer I'd give.
  16. SimonSmith

    Driven to ground in ruck

    You're looking at individual culpability. I look at team. If the offence kills the competition for the ball, there's my decision. In my head - if the reason for the offence is going to ground is that defence couldn;t bear the ruck, then play on. If they went off feet on their own and kill it, PK
  17. SimonSmith

    Statistics help required

    Minimum number of games as a qualifying threshold. Take the total number of games, and then divide by the average number of teams for that club across the season. So, you get the total score, and then divide by the number of opportunities that the club had to 'score'.
  18. SimonSmith

    Where are you this weekend - 2023/24?

    There's a ready-made gag about rugby dying a slow death in Alice. We believe that the new ground will be down near there. But the goalposts on this keep shifting, so I wouildn't hold your breath on that. I wouldn't hold my breath on there being a next season.
  19. SimonSmith

    Where are you this weekend - 2023/24?

    As mentioned previously, it's Grand Final time. Kick off at 6. No, 630. Hang on, we'll get back to you. It's the last ever game at Anzac Oval before it gets torn down. I'm sure we'll have the kind of match for the occasion....
  20. SimonSmith

    Where are you this weekend - 2023/24?

    One laugh from tonight. Decent game, well handled by the man in the middle (not me) including a general warning for high tackles. We've all gathered for a meat pie - free for the officials - and a can of something of cold(sih). General chit chat, inclduing the skipper who got the general...
Top