Hounding an interesting thought! I'm sorry if you feel that way.
I felt we had fully explored the topic and that everybody else thought it was a try, based not least on the fact that Wayne Barnes did award a try, in an excellent position therefore did not need to consider awarding a penalty try.
I did expect that you might wish to discuss as you stated within post #38:
If you've changed your mind then that's fine.
A link to a discussion from 2016 is interesting, can you advise where the law that he refers to
Is now captured?
I and World Rugby have Law 15 as Ruck and Law 16 as Maul
And Behind?
It is no longer defined, therefore it takes on the general meaning. The concept of Off feet however is defined:
and one must determine therefore that "babooning" with hand/s in the FOP is not behind the offside line.
Does that mean you agree or disagree? If you disagree then a perspective and some reasoning would progress the discussion, not least as I can consider your thoughts and reflect upon my decision making.
My whole point is that a yellow card can be given for a single cynical occurrence or due to repeated infringements where the number of offences might be variable and based upon a warning being given.
You cannot give a PT for accumulation or repetition but if any one of those transgressions meets the standard then you can. I feel the bar is being set unnecessarily high and defenders are getting away with persistent cynical play and for the benefit of the game that should be reset.